I was ready to buy the Jag XF after having a passing interest in the MKZ. Then I saw this. Not quite as nice overall as the Jag perhaps but even in Black Label the MKZ should be a few thousand less than a well optioned XF AND with about 40 more HP and torque. Many of these modern cars have traits that seem like they copy from other brands so that does not bother me at all, especially if I like the basic style. In the luxury segment only Cadillac and (most, but not all) of MB seem to stand out individually. I say "most" because the recent GLE Coupe is a copy of the BMW.
The XF, even with less engine, will probably feel lighter, more nimble and sportier overall as that is its nature. But I suspect the MKZ will still be the more comfortable and quiet car of the two and that is what I want over "sport". Too bad the MKZ's new engine is not supercharged like the XF as I prefer that over a turbo. Nonetheless, thanks to this retooling I will now be taking a real good look at the MKZ next year.